undefined | Better HN

0 pointslrvick1y ago0 comments

Not all cryptocurrencies are scams, not all traffic on Tor is CSAM, and not matrix messages are spam. Some of us use all of these decentralized systems daily for their actual intended use cases of sovereignty and privacy.

Things like money and messaging are too important to a functioning society to allow any single party to control.

We need -actually- decentralized money and -actually- decentralized communication.

MobileCoin and Signal are neither and the results are predictable.

0 comments

theamk1y ago

That's why there is no single party to control communication, and even for money there is US vs EU systems.

"Actually decentralized" has a lot of problems, especially with things like spam and scams (see also: usenet). Federation makes sure no single party has too much power, and yet allows one to have usable systems.

omnimus1y ago

Cryptocurrencies are securities not money. Unless you have force (army) that enforces your money you will not have money.

lrvickOP1y ago

Well I have clients that pay me in cryptocurrencies monthly, and I pay for goods and services with them regularly without Visa or Mastercard learning my purchasing behavior to sell to advertisers.

Sure cryptocurrency is not as widely accepted online or in person locally as US dollars, but it is far easier to spend those same places than my Euros which actually meets your definition of money.

calciphus1y ago

Surely if you're concerned about privacy, an indelible public record of all transactions you made in and out isn't the way to accomplish that?

omnimus1y ago

People will trade with amazon gift cards or weighted gold. The fact something has value and people will exchange it is not what makes thing money.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointslrvick1y ago0 comments

Things like money and messaging are too important to a functioning society to allow any single party to control.

We need -actually- decentralized money and -actually- decentralized communication.

MobileCoin and Signal are neither and the results are predictable.

0 comments

theamk1y ago

That's why there is no single party to control communication, and even for money there is US vs EU systems.

omnimus1y ago

Cryptocurrencies are securities not money. Unless you have force (army) that enforces your money you will not have money.

lrvickOP1y ago

Well I have clients that pay me in cryptocurrencies monthly, and I pay for goods and services with them regularly without Visa or Mastercard learning my purchasing behavior to sell to advertisers.

Sure cryptocurrency is not as widely accepted online or in person locally as US dollars, but it is far easier to spend those same places than my Euros which actually meets your definition of money.

calciphus1y ago

Surely if you're concerned about privacy, an indelible public record of all transactions you made in and out isn't the way to accomplish that?

omnimus1y ago

People will trade with amazon gift cards or weighted gold. The fact something has value and people will exchange it is not what makes thing money.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse