undefined | Better HN

0 pointsleononame2y ago0 comments

JS and python are just about all programming languages?

I'm not trying to be snarky, but e.g. I haven't seen it in Go, F# and Rust, some languages where I have at least seen _some_ code. I also don't remember a similar pattern in Java, C# and C nor PHP or Dart, but I will readily admit that it's I haven't coded in any of these in the last two years, so I might be a bit out of touch and I'm not super proficient in all those languages

0 comments

boxed2y ago

Go, and F# do almost all positional arguments. I think Rust too. Java, C#, C, PHP are also positional only or 99% of the time. I assume Dart too.

We are talking named/keyword/etc.

Personally I find positional arguments to be an anti-pattern in all but a very specific set of circumstances.

leononameOP2y ago

If I understand correctly, we aren't talking about named/keyword arguments. This is about a shorthand syntax in ES6 objects, nothing to do with function arguments.

In JS, when creating an object, instead of writing {name: name}, where "name" is both the key in the map as well as the variable you want it to assign to, you can do {name}, whereas e.g. in Go you would do map[string]any{"name": name}.

Edit: Or, for completeness' sake, it's the same with structs in Go, where you would instantiate a struct like this: Person{name: name}.

debugnik2y ago

C#, F# and PHP all support named arguments and they're quite common for optional parameters.

pflanze2y ago

If we're talking about constructing structs, like in `Foo { bar, baz: 123 }` (with the `bar` style shortcut in it), I have used that kind of syntax 10 times in 16 KLOC of Rust. Not a lot, but it does happen, and I found it kinda neat when LSP integration suggested its use.

I've probably used it more for pattern matching (`let Foo { bar, baz } = ...`), but haven't measured the number of instances of that idiom.

leononameOP2y ago

You're right constructing struts in Rust works with that pattern, so I'll take the Rust bit back.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

boxed2y ago

Go, and F# do almost all positional arguments. I think Rust too. Java, C#, C, PHP are also positional only or 99% of the time. I assume Dart too.

We are talking named/keyword/etc.

Personally I find positional arguments to be an anti-pattern in all but a very specific set of circumstances.

leononameOP2y ago

If I understand correctly, we aren't talking about named/keyword arguments. This is about a shorthand syntax in ES6 objects, nothing to do with function arguments.

Edit: Or, for completeness' sake, it's the same with structs in Go, where you would instantiate a struct like this: Person{name: name}.

debugnik2y ago

C#, F# and PHP all support named arguments and they're quite common for optional parameters.

pflanze2y ago

I've probably used it more for pattern matching (`let Foo { bar, baz } = ...`), but haven't measured the number of instances of that idiom.

leononameOP2y ago

You're right constructing struts in Rust works with that pattern, so I'll take the Rust bit back.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse