undefined | Better HN

0 pointsAaronFriel1y ago0 comments

This is a vague recollection, but I seem to recall Meta/Facebook engineers on HN having said they have a tool that allows engineers to author SQL or ORM-like queries on the frontend and close to where the data is used, but a compiler or post-processor turns that into an endpoint. The bundled frontend code is never given an open-ended SQL or GraphQL interface.

And perhaps not coincidentally, React introduced "server actions" as a mechanism that is very similar to that. Engineers can author what looks, ostensibly, like frontend code, merely splitting the "client" side and "server" side into separate annotated functions, and the React bundler splits those into client code, a server API handler, and transforms the client function call into the annotated server function into an HTTP API call.

Having used it for a bit it's really nice, and it doesn't result in yielding so much control to a very complex technology stack (GraphQL batchers, resolvers, etc. etc.)

0 comments

svieira1y ago

> I seem to recall Meta/Facebook engineers on HN having said they have a tool that allows engineers to author SQL or ORM-like queries on the frontend and close to where the data is used, but a compiler or post-processor turns that into an endpoint.

I don't know about on-HackerNews but there's a discussion about their "all of Facebook optimizing compiler" infrastructure from when they did the site redesign in 2020: https://engineering.fb.com/2020/05/08/web/facebook-redesign/...

> perhaps not coincidentally, React introduced "server actions" as a mechanism that is very similar to [the above]

Yep - there's also the Scala framework LiftWeb (https://www.liftweb.net/), the Elixir framework Phoenix (https://www.phoenixframework.org/) and of course the system we're using right now (Arc) that do similar things. Scaling these kinds of UUID-addressed-closures is harder (because the client sessions have to be sticky unless you can serialize closures and send them across the network between servers).

jamra1y ago

Code generation is very common at Meta. One just needs to create a query or fragment. A fragment can be spread at the root query level using relay so it will do the fetch once. It gets more complex because you can lazily query more data based on parameters you pass into GQL. It feels like magic and is really annoying imo.

hosh1y ago

Just asking for clarity, when you used “GQL”, are you referring to GraphQL or are you referring to GQL, the successor to Cypher and openCypher?

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse