undefined | Better HN

0 pointsrvnx1y ago0 comments

The same, it solves a marginal problem (people that throw away on the highway only the plastic caps, and somehow keep separate the bottle), in an absurd way that punishes all the nice users, again, just to solve a small % of very cases.

The guys who somehow enjoy throwing away plastic caps, will likely remove it anyway.

The same with the spying, all users will suffer, but those who want to work around it, will find a way.

The irony is that it makes driving more dangerous now, as you need two hands to drink from a water bottle.

0 comments

rekoil1y ago

Punish is a strong word, it slightly inconveniences all "the nice users".

It's really not that big of a deal honestly, you unscrew the bottle, flip the cap up (it kinda locks like that and stays out of your way in one of the designs I've seen, in the other it's just attached and can easily be kept out of the way with a finger), then you drink, I fail to see how you suddenly need two hands as opposed to before...

vidarh1y ago

If anything, I've come to like them because you now don't need to hold on to the cap.

salawat1y ago

>Punish is a strong word, it slightly inconveniences all "the nice users".

Stop using weak language and call a spade a spade.

gabaix1y ago

Not debating the merits of this case.

There are many regulations that slightly inconvenience the many, to address the problems of a few. Individually these cases are benign. As a group they compound complexity.

Each new reform should be evaluated on both its benefits and the burden that it brings.

rekoil1y ago

Wholeheartedly agree. But we (as a society) have neglected the environment for far too fucking long now, some inconvenience for tiny gains is valid until we start seeing societal and environmental improvements.

CalRobert1y ago

I use these caps one-handed plenty...

harperlee1y ago

> it makes driving more dangerous now, as you need two hands to drink from a water bottle.

What? That is absurd, you don't need two hands just because the lid remains attached.

rvnxOP1y ago

The lid scratches your nose or eye so you need to use the second hand to hold the lid

harperlee1y ago

(or one of the five fingers of the first hand)

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsrvnx1y ago0 comments

The guys who somehow enjoy throwing away plastic caps, will likely remove it anyway.

The same with the spying, all users will suffer, but those who want to work around it, will find a way.

The irony is that it makes driving more dangerous now, as you need two hands to drink from a water bottle.

0 comments

rekoil1y ago

Punish is a strong word, it slightly inconveniences all "the nice users".

vidarh1y ago

If anything, I've come to like them because you now don't need to hold on to the cap.

salawat1y ago

>Punish is a strong word, it slightly inconveniences all "the nice users".

Stop using weak language and call a spade a spade.

gabaix1y ago

Not debating the merits of this case.

There are many regulations that slightly inconvenience the many, to address the problems of a few. Individually these cases are benign. As a group they compound complexity.

Each new reform should be evaluated on both its benefits and the burden that it brings.

rekoil1y ago

CalRobert1y ago

I use these caps one-handed plenty...

harperlee1y ago

> it makes driving more dangerous now, as you need two hands to drink from a water bottle.

What? That is absurd, you don't need two hands just because the lid remains attached.

rvnxOP1y ago

The lid scratches your nose or eye so you need to use the second hand to hold the lid

harperlee1y ago

(or one of the five fingers of the first hand)

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse