undefined | Better HN

0 pointsCyberDildonics1y ago0 comments

So pipes are the only way to do it

Lets not get carried away. You can use ffmpeg as a library and encode buffers in a few dozen lines of C++.

0 comments

The parent comment mentioned license incompatibility, which I guess would still apply if they used ffmpeg as a library.

If the license is incompatible, it would still be incompatible regardless of whether you use library API calls or pipes.

whiterknight1y ago

And you go from having a well defined modular interface that’s flexible at runtime to a binary dependency.

CyberDildonicsOP1y ago

You have the dependency either way, but if you use the library you can have one big executable with no external dependencies and it can actually be fast.

If there wasn't a problem to solve they wouldn't have said anything. If you want something different you have to do something different.

whiterknight1y ago

The context of this discussion is that it would be better if pipes were faster. Then you would have more options.

1 more reply

Almondsetat1y ago

ffmpeg's library is notorious for being a complete and utter mess

CyberDildonicsOP1y ago

It worked extremely well when I did something almost exactly like this. I gave it buffers of pixels in memory and it spit out compressed video.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

quietbritishjim1y ago

The parent comment mentioned license incompatibility, which I guess would still apply if they used ffmpeg as a library.

seba_dos11y ago

If the license is incompatible, it would still be incompatible regardless of whether you use library API calls or pipes.

whiterknight1y ago

And you go from having a well defined modular interface that’s flexible at runtime to a binary dependency.

CyberDildonicsOP1y ago

You have the dependency either way, but if you use the library you can have one big executable with no external dependencies and it can actually be fast.

If there wasn't a problem to solve they wouldn't have said anything. If you want something different you have to do something different.

whiterknight1y ago

The context of this discussion is that it would be better if pipes were faster. Then you would have more options.

1 more reply

Almondsetat1y ago

ffmpeg's library is notorious for being a complete and utter mess

CyberDildonicsOP1y ago

It worked extremely well when I did something almost exactly like this. I gave it buffers of pixels in memory and it spit out compressed video.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse