So you can never have them as a customer again for life. This is a fine strategy as long as the very small number of people who end up here do so intentionally and after much effort. Thus proving that they will always be more trouble than they're worth.
If it's a penalty for making a single mistake that you were enabled to make then this is not going to end anywhere good for any involved party.
> In a high trust society
This gets bandied about so often it's nearly meaningless now; however, on a basic level, I do not trust my bank. I'm guessing most of their current customers don't either. So they reap what they sow.
> This isn't being asleep at the wheel either; it's prioritizing availability over accuracy
Which made since in the 1970s. We're a bit past that now, and for a multi billion dollar institution to blithely allow this happen today is absurd.