undefined | Better HN

0 pointsRinzler891y ago0 comments

>It's astonishing to me that Voyager knows where Earth is at all

It's not that astonishing when you realize astral navigation is what sailors hundreds of years ago did to navigate the seas. Just look at the stars with a sextant and with some basic trigonometry you'll know where you are exactly. The Apollo space crew had to do that by hand and eyes using a sextant too when the astral navigation computer failed.

0 comments

quesera1y ago

It would be astonishing if Voyager shipped in 1977 with computer vision capabilities that were capable of that level of object detection and discrimination and accuracy. Plus the detailed star maps for correlation. And all designed and built several years before launch!

And in fact I think it's not possible. But orienting on Sol should be achievable. Even at 15 billion miles away, it's still surely the brightest thing in the sky.

Presumably the orientation sensor is precisely in line with the parabolic antenna?

dcl1y ago

Knowing your longitude is very difficult without a clock... Can't do it with just stars iirc.

fourgreen1y ago

You can determine your longitude without a clock, but achieving precision with this method is challenging. First, you need to observe the Moon's position relative to fixed stars, which gives you the UTC time. Then, observe the Sun's position relative to the horizon to determine the local time. By comparing the two, you can calculate your longitude.

monkeyfun1y ago

How are you going to usefully use this information if you wouldn't have an obvious way to know precisely how long it's been between whenever you lost track of the moon and stars and whenever the sun is clearly visible over the horizon?

quesera1y ago

This is true and there's a fascinating history for Earth-bound (little v) voyagers!

But Voyager does not have this particular problem. :)

rbanffy1y ago

I think you can, with the Moon and where it is in relation to the Sun.

secondcoming1y ago

Does voyager have optical sensors that detect planets?

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsRinzler891y ago0 comments

>It's astonishing to me that Voyager knows where Earth is at all

0 comments

quesera1y ago

And in fact I think it's not possible. But orienting on Sol should be achievable. Even at 15 billion miles away, it's still surely the brightest thing in the sky.

Presumably the orientation sensor is precisely in line with the parabolic antenna?

dcl1y ago

Knowing your longitude is very difficult without a clock... Can't do it with just stars iirc.

fourgreen1y ago

monkeyfun1y ago

quesera1y ago

This is true and there's a fascinating history for Earth-bound (little v) voyagers!

But Voyager does not have this particular problem. :)

rbanffy1y ago

I think you can, with the Moon and where it is in relation to the Sun.

secondcoming1y ago

Does voyager have optical sensors that detect planets?

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse