undefined | Better HN

0 pointsocdtrekkie1y ago0 comments

Your lack of understanding of how you were defrauded does not change that you were. This is exactly why the government sometimes steps in to fix things even when a company is considered popular by consumers.

Everything you have bought on Android was illegally taxed, and numerous things you bought outside of Android you also overpaid for as companies tried to absorb the abusive fees as well.

You didn't "see" the anticompetitive concerns but you also never benefit from any of the options you would have if Google had operated a legal business model.

0 comments

lolinder1y ago

> Everything you have bought on Android was illegally taxed

I can't even remember the last time I bought something on the Play Store. Nearly everything I've installed for years has been open source from F-Droid or was my own personal code that I wrote and loaded onto my phone without passing through any gatekeeper.

You can keep being condescending if it makes you happy, but you could also consider that maybe you don't know me?

spunker5401y ago

Everything you have downloaded that was routed through Google’s undersea cables was illegally taxed

tick_tock_tick1y ago

I think the problem everyone is having is the government is seeing something that isn't there. We don't have a "lack of understanding" but are rather just so much more informed and educated then the legal system on this matter that we came to the correct conclusion while they failed to reach a basic understanding.

ocdtrekkieOP1y ago

This is an incredible example of the hubris and ego of tech nerds. The court got it right, because the issue isn't tech, it's economics. The idea that understanding some code makes you more qualified than a judge to handle antitrust law is laughable.

It doesn't matter that 0.01% of users can technically install F-Droid. Reality, is that 99.99% of people fundamentally can't. Apparently the judge can understand this, and you can't.

johnisgood1y ago

But you said they technically can. Can you technically do this on iOS? Lack of technical knowledge means jack shit. Write documentation for laymen as to how to do it, because they could; make it simpler for them if you so wish. Or can I make a website that has a direct link (just a tap away) to an APK and have users install that on Android? What about an app for iOS? It is a matter of "difficult" (arguable) vs "impossible", is it not?

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse