I am not trying to explain your specific brain. Next time people play the game werewolf in real life, join it for a couple of rounds, and tell the players you're not too familiar with the game, and ask them to discuss mistakes after each round. You will notice they pay a lot of attention to who said what. If you don't pay attention you become like a villager lynching random people, while if the villagers play enough attention they can prevent the wherewolf from killing the whole village most of the time.