The article only talks about the actual circuit that is behind that potentiometer.
Having built some MIDI controllers myself in the past, I noticed that rotary potentiometers allow you to better "decouple" arm/shoulder movements from hand/finger movements. I.e. when you're standing and and holding that knob, It's easier to make precise adjustments when there's a rotary knob you can "hold on to" and slowly twist your fingers, whereas with a linear potentiometer I usually have to keep a finger on the surface next to the knob to "compensate" for involuntary movements coming from my body and arm...
A lot of people talk about as it was primarily a design decision, but I suspect touch screen controls are the cheapest one out there right now.
As alluded to in the article, rotary vs. linear seems to be a proxy for the circuit which actually influences the sound. I would think that anyone claiming "mixers with rotaries always sound better" does not fully understand how they work. There's a lot of those kind of claims in the music scene.
However in these modern days with motor driven potentiometers, I guess it is less of a big deal.
It became one of the most commonly available rotary mixers, was the house mixer for many NYC clubs, and one of the mixers commonly found on tech riders of DJs who were the last to transition to CDJs.
Random bit of trivia: if you see old school photos or videos of rotary mixers in American clubs, sometimes it wasn't actually the Rane MP2016, but the Phazon SDX 3700: https://www.integralsound.com/sdx-3700-mixer It was the house mixer for Tunnel/Limelight.
Technically, regardless of the rest of the product design there are high quality potentiometers available both as linear faders or rotary knobs. I guess dirt is more likely to get into a linear fader and make it scratchy - especially in a club environment.
Anyways, it’s not the knobs that make the sound…
Pioneers have many options to quickly bail out of a train wreck mix!
At this point it's mostly a user interface problem.
They cost more than most studio mixers with far more channels and features.
The margins on these things must be insane - probably 5-10X between production cost (including R&D) and end-user price.
It's depressing that audio software still widely subjects users to this skeuomorphic failure, trying to do everything with on-screen "knobs." Ugh.
Having said that you can totally map a physical rotary encoder to a linear one in the software so this is not a good excuse.
Piece of software I use frequently has most of the important programming and setup done through touch screen and relatively little through its command line which prior version used more off, the touch screen rotary encoders are just confusing and I can never seem to get it to the right value
I will say, though, that a circle whose perimeter is partially filled in is a space-efficient way to depict the current value vs. the total range available.
I assume you're using it a lot and then it's intuitive. For novice it's not. If I click on bottom part will it operate in another direction compared with clicking on top part? Or what about if I click on left or right edge? Can I also move mouse up-down and left-right or is only one direction allowed? Is mouse-up turning knob up or down? Are these rules same in all software or knob behaves slightly different everywhere? I have no idea for any of that except if I try and see. And since I rarely use them it's always a source for frustration.
Especially compared to linear slider which is impossible to misunderstand and you can't operate in it wrong way.
- One where some type of spoon goes back and forth. This would probably just be worse than a rotary mixer though.
- One where the entire "basin" oscillates back and forth like a seesaw, like the machines they have at the blood bank to make sure the blood mixes well with the anticoagulant in the bag(s).
- One where the basin is airtight and vibrated up and down vigorously. I could see this work quite well for dry-ish mixtures of different particles, like if you have flour and sugar together in a container and want them mixed.
Turned out it's just about rotary vs linear potentiometers. Or I misunderstood everything.