undefined | Better HN

0 pointskortilla1y ago0 comments

I think there is a better argument for banning anyone under the age of 30 from voting than there is for anything as low as a limit of 60 for voting.

0 comments

lukan1y ago

So as a compromise only allow people between 30 and 60 to vote?

(Which would be hilarious, as it means, allmost no one voted in office would be allowed to vote themself anymore, unless of course that would change, too)

robinei1y ago

On the flip side, it seems evident that younger people tend to vote for the betterment of all, while older people tend to shift toward voting for «themselves».

akkad331y ago

Why is that evident? Any evidence for it?

robinei1y ago

I’m talking of the typical left/right split. Where leftist policies tend toward redistribution of wealth to the benefit of broader swathes, while right oriented policies tend to at least lead to more concentration of wealth. Maybe it is an outdated bias, but until now at least my impression is that young people have had a greater tendency toward some form of humanistic idealism.

akkad331y ago

That's the traditional stereotype, but I have a hard time believing those whose internet presence is mostly manifested as Twitter stan wars and tiktok trends care about greater ideals than the next viral trend

kortillaOP1y ago

It’s just different forms of selfishness. Many young adults on the left voting for free shit from the government are voting for it because they would get it. They don’t actually care about the VA or whatever other stuff they don’t qualify for.

Then they get decent paying jobs and vote for the party that gets rid of the programs they no longer qualify for in order to reduce their taxation.

a-french-anon1y ago

>I’m talking of the typical left/right split. Where leftist policies tend toward redistribution of wealth to the benefit of broader swathes

Broader swathes which they're part of. This is just the millennia old has and has-nots, don't fall for wishful thinking this base.

hnthrowaway65431y ago

[flagged]

LeafItAlone1y ago

>Frankly, society would be a lot better if the childless couldn't vote; leave voting to people who have a stake in society's future!

Whoa now. Just because I am childless doesn’t mean I don’t care about future generations. I still have friends and family that do have children and I vote with that in mind.

1 more reply

robinei1y ago

Maybe idealism is dead and even the youth have been corrupted these days.

maeil1y ago

Hard to tell whether you are being sarcastic or not; just in case you aren't, it's trivial to confirm that few people vote in a game-theory optimal manner.

LeafItAlone1y ago

>I think there is a better argument for banning anyone under the age of 30 from voting

Please expand on this.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

lukan1y ago

So as a compromise only allow people between 30 and 60 to vote?

(Which would be hilarious, as it means, allmost no one voted in office would be allowed to vote themself anymore, unless of course that would change, too)

robinei1y ago

On the flip side, it seems evident that younger people tend to vote for the betterment of all, while older people tend to shift toward voting for «themselves».

akkad331y ago

Why is that evident? Any evidence for it?

robinei1y ago

akkad331y ago

kortillaOP1y ago

Then they get decent paying jobs and vote for the party that gets rid of the programs they no longer qualify for in order to reduce their taxation.

a-french-anon1y ago

>I’m talking of the typical left/right split. Where leftist policies tend toward redistribution of wealth to the benefit of broader swathes

Broader swathes which they're part of. This is just the millennia old has and has-nots, don't fall for wishful thinking this base.

hnthrowaway65431y ago

[flagged]

LeafItAlone1y ago

>Frankly, society would be a lot better if the childless couldn't vote; leave voting to people who have a stake in society's future!

Whoa now. Just because I am childless doesn’t mean I don’t care about future generations. I still have friends and family that do have children and I vote with that in mind.

1 more reply

robinei1y ago

Maybe idealism is dead and even the youth have been corrupted these days.

maeil1y ago

Hard to tell whether you are being sarcastic or not; just in case you aren't, it's trivial to confirm that few people vote in a game-theory optimal manner.

LeafItAlone1y ago

>I think there is a better argument for banning anyone under the age of 30 from voting

Please expand on this.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse