Kibi – A text editor in less than 1024 lines of code, written in Rust (opens in new tab)

(terminaltrove.com)

20 pointsjkstill1y ago8 comments

8 comments

In case the reference is not clear, the name is likely a callback to antirez’s Kilo[1], an editor in <1000 lines of C.

the repo is here btw. i appreciate that the dependency tree is appropriately minimal. also impressive how many comments are included in the source. maybe they’re not counted towards the LOC?

rc001y ago

Maybe the comments were written by another LLM. It certainly has that smell.

James_K1y ago

  /tmp/kibi % cloc .
        98 text files.
        89 unique files.
        11 files ignored.

  github.com/AlDanial/cloc v 1.96  T=0.05 s (1936.6 files/s, 82405.1 lines/s)
  -------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  Language                     files          blank        comment           code
  -------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  Rust                            15            241            379           1480
  Markdown                         5            179             22            502
  INI                             50              3             20            388
  YAML                            10             36             21            281
  XML                              1              0              1             62
  TOML                             3             10              1             57
  Bourne Shell                     1             13              8             46
  JSON                             2              0              0             31
  Dockerfile                       1              2              0              3
  SVG                              1              0              0              1
  -------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  SUM:                            89            484            452           2851
  -------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I'm not sure if this counts as less than 1024.

diath1y ago

Even though that's 400-ish over, the readme states:

   1.: Counted per platform, excluding tests and Clippy directives, see count_loc.sh

However, I personally feel like it's a stupid metric anyway because that doesn't count dependencies (although kibi specifically seems to have minimal dependencies), and at some point you could simply abstract your code away into a library and use it as a dependency to prune some lines from the codebase.

James_K1y ago

It also excludes tests, which is how they reach such a low number. It seems they are trying to count the number of lines actually used in the executable. I can't see the value in this metric. If they want to talk about executable size, they should just use that. If they want to talk about the complexity of maintaining their project, then surely you must count all lines because those still make the project harder to maintain. I guess they're trying to measure the logical complexity of the final result, but I can't for the life of me think why a user or developer would care about this.

t14n1y ago

There are some OS specific files (unix.rx, windows.rs, etc) that you can discount (imo).

If you really wanted to codegolf the repo, I'm sure you can make it literally <1024 lines.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

8 comments

mananaysiempre1y ago

In case the reference is not clear, the name is likely a callback to antirez’s Kilo[1], an editor in <1000 lines of C.

[1] http://antirez.com/news/108

skavi1y ago

https://github.com/ilai-deutel/kibi

the repo is here btw. i appreciate that the dependency tree is appropriately minimal. also impressive how many comments are included in the source. maybe they’re not counted towards the LOC?

rc001y ago

Maybe the comments were written by another LLM. It certainly has that smell.

James_K1y ago

  /tmp/kibi % cloc .
        98 text files.
        89 unique files.
        11 files ignored.

  github.com/AlDanial/cloc v 1.96  T=0.05 s (1936.6 files/s, 82405.1 lines/s)
  -------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  Language                     files          blank        comment           code
  -------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  Rust                            15            241            379           1480
  Markdown                         5            179             22            502
  INI                             50              3             20            388
  YAML                            10             36             21            281
  XML                              1              0              1             62
  TOML                             3             10              1             57
  Bourne Shell                     1             13              8             46
  JSON                             2              0              0             31
  Dockerfile                       1              2              0              3
  SVG                              1              0              0              1
  -------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  SUM:                            89            484            452           2851
  -------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I'm not sure if this counts as less than 1024.

diath1y ago

Even though that's 400-ish over, the readme states:

   1.: Counted per platform, excluding tests and Clippy directives, see count_loc.sh

James_K1y ago

t14n1y ago

There are some OS specific files (unix.rx, windows.rs, etc) that you can discount (imo).

If you really wanted to codegolf the repo, I'm sure you can make it literally <1024 lines.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse