Yeah, I’m not much interested in “what’s consciousness?” but I do think the automatic-versus-thinking distinction matters for understanding what LLMs do, and what we might expect them to be able to do, and when and to what degree we need to second-guess them.

A human doesn’t just confidently spew paragraphs legit-looking but entirely wrong crap, unless they’re trying to deceive or be funny—an LLM isn’t trying to do anything, though, there’s no motivation, it doesn’t like you (it doesn’t like—it doesn’t it, one might even say), sometimes it definitely will just give you a beautiful and elaborate lie simply because its rulebook told it to, in a context and in a way that would be extremely weird if a person did it.