undefined | Better HN

0 pointsphilwelch13y ago0 comments

I think it's better for smart people not to have patronizing attitudes about the rest of humanity, but that's just me.

I also think that charitable gestures towards men risking their lives and suffering great hardship to protect entire civilizations are categorically a different thing from a commercial product. I think the troops probably felt this way as well, which is really the crux of the whole issue, isn't it?

There's a massive difference between "here's a little something to say thanks for fighting for our country" and "doughnuts for sale"--and one is hardly a substitute for the other.

0 comments

vacri13y ago

There's a massive difference between "here's a little something to say thanks for fighting for our country"

Why should that gesture be coming from the Red Cross, an organisation that's supposed to transcend nationalities and help all people regardless of politics?

philwelchOP13y ago

You're probably confusing the International Committee of the Red Cross (which is the organization you're describing) with the American Red Cross (which is explicitly American, and assists US troops overseas along with other charitable activities).

As for the moral value of providing a gesture of thanks to people who are literally fighting the Nazis, I'll let you work that out for yourself.

vacri13y ago

Firstly, yes, I was confusing the international versus american. My apologies.

Secondly, fuck you for that second statement (and somewhat implying that my morals are twisted). Those kinds of judgement calls are exactly why the Red Cross and MSF are apolitical. "Fuck those guys over there, they're -foo-" is precisely what these organisations area against, a core part of why they were formed.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsphilwelch13y ago0 comments

I think it's better for smart people not to have patronizing attitudes about the rest of humanity, but that's just me.

There's a massive difference between "here's a little something to say thanks for fighting for our country" and "doughnuts for sale"--and one is hardly a substitute for the other.

0 comments

vacri13y ago

There's a massive difference between "here's a little something to say thanks for fighting for our country"

Why should that gesture be coming from the Red Cross, an organisation that's supposed to transcend nationalities and help all people regardless of politics?

philwelchOP13y ago

As for the moral value of providing a gesture of thanks to people who are literally fighting the Nazis, I'll let you work that out for yourself.

vacri13y ago

Firstly, yes, I was confusing the international versus american. My apologies.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse