undefined | Better HN

0 pointsscarface_741y ago0 comments

There is so much that goes into gathering requirements for any large implementation that is not just about asking the requirements. There is the entire management and navigation of organizational politics and priorities, getting to the bottom of XYProblems, users not really knowing what they want and being able to help them get there, etc.

0 comments

s__s1y ago

At that level, that’s the role of a product manager. We aren’t going to see software engineers all transform in to project managers. Most don’t have the skills, but more importantly there’s no need for that many PM’s.

scarface_74OP1y ago

Project managers don’t have the technical skillset necessary.

As far as not having the skills, that’s the entire problem that most software engineers are going to have if they don’t understand the business. If you look at the leveling guidelines of every tech company, the higher you go up, the more you are expected to deal with “ambiguity”.

As a “staff software architect”, I am part project manager, part technical lead. But the last thing I want at that level is to play telephone and have someone constantly coming between me and stakeholder.

And some software engineers will be stuck fighting thousands of other commodity ticket takers fighting for scraps. We see that now without AI taking jobs.

s__s1y ago

You have basically just circled back to what I said initially:

> I don't foresee software engineers going extinct, but there will most definitely be a lot fewer of them.

Your bad attitude, calling most software engineers “ticket takers”, while envisioning yourself as being an un-replaceable genius is extremely common in these discussions. It’s clearly an emotional reaction.

And I understand. AI is going to decimate the industry (along with many others).

Even for those who are truly un-replaceable, for many their companies business model itself will easily collapse. I can look at the list of b2b sass software I use right now and literally all of them will have zero value soon when an AI agent can in house their service in a day.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

s__s1y ago

scarface_74OP1y ago

Project managers don’t have the technical skillset necessary.

And some software engineers will be stuck fighting thousands of other commodity ticket takers fighting for scraps. We see that now without AI taking jobs.

s__s1y ago

You have basically just circled back to what I said initially:

> I don't foresee software engineers going extinct, but there will most definitely be a lot fewer of them.

And I understand. AI is going to decimate the industry (along with many others).

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse