undefined | Better HN

0 pointsgcp13y ago0 comments

MPEG2 isn't an audio codec, it's a suite of standards. But based on my experience writing hardware encoders for this use case, you're talking about MPEG1 Layer 2 audio.

Opus outperforms that greatly, but it's not going to outperform MPEG1 Layer 2 at 256kbps while only outputting 64kbps itself. (Will likely need >= 96kbps for that).

0 comments

marquis13y ago

Thanks, that was what I was referencing. How well do you think Opus will compare to AAC?

gcpOP13y ago

I already posted tests results elsewhere in this topic. It outperforms it at low bitrates. I suspect also at higher ones but once both codecs get imperceptible for most listeners (which is the case for AAC and Opus >128kbps) it's very hard to get statistically significant results.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsgcp13y ago0 comments

MPEG2 isn't an audio codec, it's a suite of standards. But based on my experience writing hardware encoders for this use case, you're talking about MPEG1 Layer 2 audio.

Opus outperforms that greatly, but it's not going to outperform MPEG1 Layer 2 at 256kbps while only outputting 64kbps itself. (Will likely need >= 96kbps for that).

0 comments

marquis13y ago

Thanks, that was what I was referencing. How well do you think Opus will compare to AAC?

gcpOP13y ago

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse