undefined | Better HN

0 pointslatch13y ago0 comments

With Dart you need to send the Dart framework over the wire. That's my point, you've replaced the flexibility of sending the framework(s) you want/need and haven't gained anything.

Sure, the Dart framework is smaller, but it also does less. If you don't need everything that comes with jQuery, you can swap it out for something smaller, like zepto or TinyDOM - which make Dart look massive.

jQuery, zepto, xyz, abc, ... all give you a consistent way to manipulate DOM objects.

0 comments

spankalee13y ago

Eventually (maybe already) you wont' have to send the whole Dart framework down the wire, just the parts you use. And because it's compiled some cases will not use any "framework" at all that would need to be downloaded, they will just be compiled into the equivalent JavaScript.

Take the button creation example.

With jQuery you have to use an odd syntax, IMO, and it requires the whole jQuery library to be downloaded:

  var button = $('<button>');

With Dart creating a button follows the same syntax as creating other objects is compiled away:

  var button = new ButtonElement();

which compiles to JS:

  var button = document.createElement('button');

This way you get a nice DOM and in some cases no overhead at all. Other cases might have runtime code that needs to be included like jQuery or Zepto, but without compilation they will always have to include their whole library.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse