undefined | Better HN

0 pointsmytailorisrich1y ago0 comments

There is always a degree of incoherence in people's beliefs and actions.

A good one along the lines of your comment, IMHO, is how most Europeans are very happy to promote ID cards and to be asked for theirs all the time while always complaining about "privacy" and against "surveillance".

For instance in France you must show your ID to buy even a prepaid SIM card, but then again the police can ask to see your ID with little justification. Or how they ask for ID when checking your ticket in the TGV high-speed train...

0 comments

Jolter1y ago

Are you insinuating that if you're in the US, you could refuse to show your ID to a police officer when they ask for it?

Go ahead and try that, tell us how it goes...

(No, there is no requirement to be carrying your ID card in any EU countries that I'm aware of. However, most jurisdictions require you to state your identity if questioned by police as a suspect. At least here in Sweden, if you're a suspect they are allowed to detain you "for identification" if you refuse.)

mytailorisrichOP1y ago

Why the aggressive tone?

I am not expert in the US, and it has actually nothing to do with my comment, but I believe that police in the US might ask you to identify yourself in some circumstances (which is quite different from having to show an ID).

What I mentioned regarding France is that you must show an ID (passport, ID card or driving license) or face being detained at the police station when asked by police. You do not need to be a suspect of anything to be required to show an ID.

Jolter1y ago

I was certainly not going for an agressive tone. I'm trying to say that police all over the world will want to know whom they are talking to, especially if you're a suspect. I don't think it's a world of difference between the US and an "average EU country" there.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

Jolter1y ago

Are you insinuating that if you're in the US, you could refuse to show your ID to a police officer when they ask for it?

Go ahead and try that, tell us how it goes...

mytailorisrichOP1y ago

Why the aggressive tone?

Jolter1y ago

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse