undefined | Better HN

0 pointsmort961y ago0 comments

> It's saving semicolon-separated CSV files with the comma as a decimal point.

It's not though, is what I'm saying. It's saving semicolon-separated files, not CSV files. CSV files have commas separating the values. Saying that Excel saves "semicolon-separated CSV files" is nonsensical.

I can save binary data in a .txt file, that doesn't make it a "text file with binary data"; it's a binary file with a stupid name.

0 comments

oezi1y ago

Sorry, but what Excel does is save to a file with a CSV extension. This format is well defined and includes ways to specify encoding and separator to be readable under different locales.

This format is not comma separated values. But Excel calls it CSV.

The headaches comes if people assume that a csv file must be comma separated.

mort96OP1y ago

I don't care what Excel calls it. As I said, if I name a file .txt but stuff it with binary data, it's not a text file.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse