undefined | Better HN

0 pointsdzaima1y ago0 comments

The only case I recall of denormals specifically being improperly handled is 32-bit ARM NEON; and indeed clang and gcc just don't use it without -ffast-math.

NaNs indeed can get different bit patterns, but my point was that, given that you need to explicitly bit-reinterpret the NaN to have that affect anything, that can't really affect most code. I guess perhaps blindly hashing a NaNs bits? (that of course goes under your "you weren't handling NaNs […] properly anyway")

0 comments

AlotOfReading1y ago

The Intel compiler used to (and possibly still does) set the SSE FTZ bit by default, leading to a situation where two different FPUs on the same chip (x87 and SSE) had different FP configs. I was indeed thinking of ARM though. I've come across chips with both VFP and NEON where they're handled differently.

For NaNs, if we're being strict then you don't need to reach that far. Here's one example from LLVM:

https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/issues/43070)

This can occasionally result in visible bugs, like: https://github.com/rust-lang/rust/issues/110174

You have to be pretty nitpicky to care about this stuff and it's not an issue in practice, but it's a reproducibility violation because it deviates from the standard nonetheless.

dzaimaOP1y ago

Intel compilers default to -ffast-math wholesale, so they're just entirely broken: https://godbolt.org/z/18xoEf5Gf

Those LLVM issues are unrelated afaict - the former is high-level IR optimizations that just result in non-reproducible NaN bit patterns (and the things that wouldn't be just NaN bit patterns I can't even repro on the reported llvm 8.0 or any other version I tested)

The latter though is indeed a proper compiler bug, min/max are an awful mess... didn't know that the ARM fminnm/fmaxnm that were that funky though, caring about sNaN vs qNaN... makes them essentially unusable for compilers (not even useful in known-not-NaN contexts, as then fmin/fmax are equivalent)

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse