undefined | Better HN

0 pointsmintsuki10mo ago0 comments

That is a very niche use case, and also won't really work on most real BIOS machines as they actually check for a proper MBR and/or BPB (and no GPT), which is also why GPT on BIOS support is very spotty, since a lot of BIOSes will detect the GPT and refuse to boot, or refuse to boot in legacy (CSM) mode.

In any case that is far beyond the original scope of booting old PC OSes, which MBR support alone serves really well (99.9% of the way there, really), which is why I assumed by default you were thinking of MBR, not some other weird scheme.

0 comments

superkuh10mo ago

GPT is not UEFI. It's just the format of the storage device. I have many computers with GPT formatted disks with actual master boot records at the start of the disk that boot MBR on both original BIOS machines and CSM BIOS machines.

MBR is two things with the same name. It is both the format of the storage device and describes a booting mode using a master boot record and up to 4 partitions.

GPT is one thing. It is a format for a storage device. It is the alternative to the MBR format for storage devices. It has nothing to do with (U)EFI.

BIOS or BIOS/csm are not types of formats for storage devices. They are types of boot processes. (U)EFI is another type of boot process.

You can easily mix and match boot types (BIOS/csm vs UEFI) and storage device format types (GPT vs MBR). As others have said, there may be some slight incompatibilities on some rare hardware/software configs, but mostly it just works.

mintsukiOP10mo ago

I know every word of what I said in the message you're replying to. While what you said is mostly accurate, as in MBR != BIOS and GPT != UEFI, never in my original message have I stated that that is the case. And the rest of what you said is incorrect, as per my original message.

I invite you to read what I said again.

superkuh10mo ago

Oof. On re-read I see now this sub-thread's topic was "non-GPT, non-MBR". So my "response" was ... off topic and useless. Sorry.

I am not sure what I said that was incorrect though. As I'm always looking to learn, which bit? I am currently assuming the 'rest' about GPT on true BIOS machines. I suppose I have never booted off GPT formatted disks in true BIOS machines. I always boot off MBR formatted disks and just used the GPT as storage/etc.

But I'm unclear on how this would break things since you can still have the MBR in the first sector on a GPT formatted disk. And how could the true BIOS motherboards detect GPT format on the disks when they don't know about it?

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsmintsuki10mo ago0 comments

0 comments

superkuh10mo ago

MBR is two things with the same name. It is both the format of the storage device and describes a booting mode using a master boot record and up to 4 partitions.

GPT is one thing. It is a format for a storage device. It is the alternative to the MBR format for storage devices. It has nothing to do with (U)EFI.

BIOS or BIOS/csm are not types of formats for storage devices. They are types of boot processes. (U)EFI is another type of boot process.

mintsukiOP10mo ago

I invite you to read what I said again.

superkuh10mo ago

Oof. On re-read I see now this sub-thread's topic was "non-GPT, non-MBR". So my "response" was ... off topic and useless. Sorry.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse