undefined | Better HN

0 pointsepistasis9mo ago0 comments

That is absolutely untrue. One can comment on the unreliability and inappropriateness of a source without impugning the material, and that's exactly what's been done here. I don't think you are fully reading what was written.

0 comments

sitkack9mo ago

In a rhetorical sense, yes. But it doesn't invalidate the logic of the statement. Your viewpoint would that of an attorney, not a logician.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsepistasis9mo ago0 comments

That is absolutely untrue. One can comment on the unreliability and inappropriateness of a source without impugning the material, and that's exactly what's been done here. I don't think you are fully reading what was written.

0 comments

sitkack9mo ago

In a rhetorical sense, yes. But it doesn't invalidate the logic of the statement. Your viewpoint would that of an attorney, not a logician.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse