undefined | Better HN

0 pointsGud9mo ago0 comments

No offense, but why would you speak about a topic you know little about?

0 comments

Possibly because smart people with expertise, usually hard-won through years of focus and study, make the common fallacy that they are experts in unrelated areas, even if they haven't put in the effort to become experts.

Too many secretly believe they're Renaissance polymaths, instead of being humble enough to admit they don't know something.

BigHatLogan9mo ago

Really well said. I would even go further and say that the "smart people with expertise" even disagree on matters like this and are operating on imperfect, vague information. Knowing that, it seems even more ridiculous to ask passersby about their opinion on this. Of course you can have an opinion, but keep in mind you're likely operating in 99% fog. Just my two cents.

abirch9mo ago

I love Tetlock's "Super Forecasting" Basically experts only do slightly better than random on predicting in their area of expertise.

1 more reply

ivan_gammel9mo ago

It is absolutely normal and acceptable to talk about topics you don’t know about. If you are wrong, someone will tell you. If you are smart, you will learn from it better and faster than trying to study the topic yourself, because people who are familiar with the subject may know things you don’t know you need to know.

And of course sometimes being deeply involved makes experts less objective and outsider perspective may bring some fresh air to the conversation.

JumpCrisscross9mo ago

> why would you speak about a topic you know little about?

I have knowledge about adjacent topics. I add the caveat in case someone has a source that substantiates or refutes my hypothesis because I’m more interested in learning

GudOP9mo ago

Ok, thanks for answering.

I think it’s extremely common to be opinionated about things we don’t know much about. I don’t even know if that’s good or bad, I do find it interesting.

zoklet-enjoyer9mo ago

That's kind of how most things seem to be. People go about their lives and even if they have strong opinions about something like that, they probably aren't going to do much about it.

gosub1009mo ago

It makes sense to extrapolate based on what we know. In the US, the media and advocacy groups manufacture controversy and outrage. He's testing the possibility that maybe the same pattern applies there too.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse