undefined | Better HN

0 pointsomnimus7mo ago0 comments

I wouldn't underestimate what can happen if 1/3 of your workforce is displaced and put aside with nothing to do.

People are usually obedient because they have something in life and they are very busy with work. So they don't have time or headspace to really care about politics. When suddenly big numbers of people start to more care about politics it leads to organizing and all kinds of political changes.

What i mean is that it wouldn't be current political class pushing things like UBI. At same time it seems that some of current elites are preparing for this and want to get rid of elections altogether to keep the status quo.

0 comments

TheOtherHobbes7mo ago

I wouldn't underestimate how easily AI will suppress this through a combination of ultrasurveillance, psychological and emotional modelling, and personally targeted persuasion delivered by chatbot etc.

If all else fails you can simply bomb city blocks into submission. Or arrange targeted drone decapitations of troublemakers. (Possibly literally.)

The automation and personalisation of social and political control - and violence - is the biggest difference this time around. The US has already seen a revolution in the effectiveness of mass state propaganda, and AI has the potential to take that up another level.

What's more likely to happen is survivors will move off-grid altogether - away from the big cities, off the Internet, almost certainly disconnected and unable to organise unless communication starts happening on electronic backchannels.

nerptastic7mo ago

Speculating here, but I don't believe that the government would have the time or organization to do this. Widespread political unrest caused by job losses would be the first step. Almost as soon as there is some type of AI that can replace mass amounts of workers, people will be out on the streets - most people don't have 1-2 months of living expenses saved up. At that point, the government would realize that SHTF - but it's too late, people would be protesting / rioting in droves - doesn't matter how many drones you can produce, or whether or not you can psychologically manipulate people when all they want is... food.

I could be entirely wrong, but it feels like if AI were to get THAT good, the government would be affected just as much as the working class. We'd more likely see total societal collapse rather than the government maintaining power and manipulating / suppressing the people.

anonandwhistle7mo ago

That is a lot assumption right there. Starving masses can't logically and physically fight with AI or government for long. They become weak after weeks or months? At that point government would be smaller and controlled probably be part of AI owners.

IF they dont have 1-2 months of living expenses saved, they die. They can'be a big threat even in millions??? they dont have organization capacity or anything that matches

omnimusOP7mo ago

I am not sure AI will be that much more different or effective than what has been done by rich elites forever. There are already gigantic agencies and research centres focusing on opinion manipulation. And these are working - just look at how poor masses are voting for policies that are clearly against them (lowering taxes for the rich etc).

But all these voters still have their place in the world and don't have free time to do anything. I don't think people are so powerless once you really displace big potion of them.

For example look at people here - everywhere you can read how it's harder to find programming job. Companies are roleplaying the narrative that they don't need programmers anymore. Do you think this army of jobless programmers will become mind controlled by tech they themselves created? Or they will use their free time to do something about their situation?

Displacing/canceling/deleting/killing individuals in society works because most people wave their and thinking this couldn't happen to them. One you start getting into bigger potions of people the dynamic is different.

vkou7mo ago

Getting rid of peaceful processes for transferring power is not going to be the big win that they think it is.

anonandwhistle7mo ago

This is why Palantir and others exist to stop masses.It´s been only tested but it will only grow from there and stop millions of people. SV you built this

omnimusOP7mo ago

Oh yeah Peter Thiel was exactly one of the people i meant when i said elites are preparing for it.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

TheOtherHobbes7mo ago

If all else fails you can simply bomb city blocks into submission. Or arrange targeted drone decapitations of troublemakers. (Possibly literally.)

nerptastic7mo ago

anonandwhistle7mo ago

IF they dont have 1-2 months of living expenses saved, they die. They can'be a big threat even in millions??? they dont have organization capacity or anything that matches

omnimusOP7mo ago

But all these voters still have their place in the world and don't have free time to do anything. I don't think people are so powerless once you really displace big potion of them.

vkou7mo ago

Getting rid of peaceful processes for transferring power is not going to be the big win that they think it is.

anonandwhistle7mo ago

This is why Palantir and others exist to stop masses.It´s been only tested but it will only grow from there and stop millions of people. SV you built this

omnimusOP7mo ago

Oh yeah Peter Thiel was exactly one of the people i meant when i said elites are preparing for it.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse