undefined | Better HN

0 pointsverdverm7mo ago0 comments

a very opinionated piece that leads by conclusion rather than building up to it.

The main part of ATProto that is centralized is the PLC and that will eventually be made (most likely) into a consortium. PDS hosting is debatable

That being said, it should be possible to run completely independent atproto networks today. We have several dev infra setups for doing it in the ecosystem

0 comments

dokyun7mo ago

> it should be possible to run completely independent atproto networks today

But does anyone do it? It doesn't really matter if it's /theoretically possible/ if no one actually does it.

Running an ActivityPub server is piss easy, anyone can do it on a $5 VPS or in their basement, and that's one of its big strengths.

poink7mo ago

BlackSky seems to be run by a competent dev with a high enough profile that I see his posts regularly without following him directly

Based on his progress posts it seems that ATproto is intentionally moving in the right direction and BlackSky has progressed to the point he’s asking for volunteers to move off Bluesky and try out his implementations

uncircle7mo ago

What is this BlackSky you're talking about?

1 more reply

danabramov7mo ago

People are doing it yeah. The post linked in the comment above is already outdated, see https://whtwnd.com/bnewbold.net/3lo7a2a4qxg2l for relatively recent developments.

nulfrost7mo ago

> Running an ActivityPub server is piss easy, anyone can do it on a $5 VPS or in their basement, and that's one of its big strengths.

same statement can be applied to running a bluesky PDS. Here are the server recs: https://github.com/bluesky-social/pds?tab=readme-ov-file#sel...

runako7mo ago

I could be mistaken, but I believe BlackSky is pretty close today.

ludicrousdispla7mo ago

I am finding it very informative.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse