Personally I have no issues with AI bots, that properly identify themselves, from scraping content as if the site operator doesn't want it to happen they can easily block the offending bot(s).
We built our own proof-of-work challenge that we enable on client sites/accounts as they come under 'attack' and it has been incredible how effective it is. That said I do think it is only a matter of time before the tactics change and these "malicious" AI bots are adapted to look more human / like real browsers.
I mean honestly it wouldn't be _that_ hard to enable them to run javascript or to emulate a real/accurate User-Agent. That said they could even run headless versions of the browser engines...
It's definitely going to be cat-and-mouse.
The most brutal honest truth is that if they throttled themselves as not to totally crash whatever site they're trying to scrape we'd probably have never noticed or gone through the trouble of writing our own proof-of-work challenge.
Unfortunately those writing/maintaining these AI bots that hammer sites to death probably either have no concept of the damage it can do or they don't care.
