undefined | Better HN

0 pointsbaq6mo ago0 comments

Hardware is so broken that getting useful functionality basically amounts to casting magic spells and drivers are supposed to be master wizards who know all the points where the spell book is wrong or incomplete. If you think drivers are bad, don’t look at the hardware, you’ll get depressed.

0 comments

sitkack6mo ago

This is fundamentally the problem. Just like being able to send OTA updates has enshittified all software, having this magic shim layer that fixes hardware problems has enabled shit hardware, and then foisted all this complexity into the OS. Many abstractions are like bondo, they just cover rot.

I am addressing your comment and eru's question about drivers.

The hardware that would normally need drivers should present itself over a fixed, well documented protocol. Think virtio, or usb device classes but more comprehensive. This would also allow for said hardware to rigorously tested before it ever sees an OS. As it is now, because the hardware is shit and requires a driver, you can't really test the hardware in a way that an OS would expect because it requires the OS driver to even start to function. The job of the OS is now to repair broken hardware.

https://docs.oasis-open.org/virtio/virtio/v1.3/virtio-v1.3.h...

https://wiki.osdev.org/Virtio

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USB_communications_device_clas... (the only good thing to come out of usb)

rcxdude6mo ago

The problem with your wish is that's you're kinda getting it in some cases, and it's a bit of a monkey paw. Hardware vendors are increasingly creating systems that abstract away the underlying hardware from the OS (usually by writing their own software on some other core that really drives the hardware), but the problem is they're generally closed, buggy, and leaky, and so the OS stops really being the OS of the system and instead you have a collection of barely-related subsystems that it's really difficult to get to work together effectively, and way more security holes than you can shake a stick at. (Oh, and they're usually only ever tested against one particular OS and so they're not actually particularly portable)

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse