undefined | Better HN

0 pointssojsurf6mo ago0 comments

I live near Detroit, not Hollywood. Most union workers are not movie stars, directors, staring quarterbacks or soccer stars. Most are cops, teachers and automotive workers.

Speaking with a friend around me who worked in automotive, the unions are a double edged sword. They provide security for you, but they also provide security for a bunch of folks who realized they won't get fired if they put in the bare minimum. My friend found this incredibly frustrating.

Many unions here put large amounts of money toward political goals I don't support. If I want a job at such a company, under Michigan state law I can be compelled to pay the dues, even if the union is working against me politically. Until I can work somewhere without being forced to pay union dues, I am not interested in those jobs, even if they pay more.

0 comments

nradov6mo ago

Sometimes they won't get fired even if they put in less than the bare minimum. I know a number of people who have worked in the Detroit area auto industry and they tell stories of hourly workers who kept their jobs after being caught literally sleeping or drunk on the clock. Union leadership doesn't seem to understand that by defending those slackers they might get a temporary "win" and stick it to management, but ultimately it just encourages management to move production elsewhere.

triceratops6mo ago

Agreed about the shortsightedness of unions.

triceratops6mo ago

> they won't get fired if they put in the bare minimum

Why should anyone, union or not, be fired for that? Not promoted, not given raises, sure that's fine. The "bare minimum" is by definition the least acceptable level of productivity from a worker.

> I can be compelled to pay the dues, even if the union is working against me politically

Depends on what that means. Politically its job is to get you the most pay and job security possible.

throwaway674996mo ago

Not sure where to mention these, but they seem relevant to this part of the thread: Ben Hamper's Rivethead is a good read about working on the line during the decline of Flint. It's an excellent companion to Michael Moore's Roger & Me.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointssojsurf6mo ago0 comments

I live near Detroit, not Hollywood. Most union workers are not movie stars, directors, staring quarterbacks or soccer stars. Most are cops, teachers and automotive workers.

0 comments

nradov6mo ago

triceratops6mo ago

Agreed about the shortsightedness of unions.

triceratops6mo ago

> they won't get fired if they put in the bare minimum

Why should anyone, union or not, be fired for that? Not promoted, not given raises, sure that's fine. The "bare minimum" is by definition the least acceptable level of productivity from a worker.

> I can be compelled to pay the dues, even if the union is working against me politically

Depends on what that means. Politically its job is to get you the most pay and job security possible.

throwaway674996mo ago

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse