To be nitpicky, React itself does not specify that state management must be global. It was a popular pattern, starting with Facebook's blog post on Flux and made popular by Redux. And certain newer features like hydration/SSR and suspense more or less require a global store because their data can't be kept in the tree. But in many cases you can keep state local with useState and Recoil/Jotai and frameworks that keep global state/caches abstracted away like TanStack Query.

For progressive enhancement, I like the island approach used by Astro. I do think that most developers are not just building static sites though. And if you're generating HTML on the server side and then updating it dynamically on the client, having two different languages (Java/Go/Python on the backend, JS on the frontend) becomes messy pretty quick.

There are times where you should build the simplest solution that meets your needs, and times when you should think ahead to future use cases so you don't box yourself into a corner. And picking a framework is a big part of that process.

I just use svelte. It works with raw html.

i'm bookmarking this comment. great cascading list!

agree as a 10+ year customer facing product person doing tons of react.