undefined | Better HN

0 pointsrayiner8mo ago0 comments

India has 130 million college graduates, and 70% of H1bs. Mexico, Brazil, and Colombia together have over 50 million graduates, but only around 2% of H1bs combined.

0 comments

jonathanstrange8mo ago

So the US is more popular among Indians than among Mexicans, Brazilians, and Colombians. What is the point?

And why these countries when I've already said the same about Indians vs. Chinese?

rayinerOP8mo ago

The point is that it strongly suggests the system is being abused by India. Even excluding developed countries where people might lack incentive to move, India doesn’t come close to having 70% of “the talent.” Latin America alone probably has as many college graduates as India, accounting for higher college attendance rates. But Latin America accounts for a small share of H1bs while India accounts for 70%.

134158mo ago

That argument is not sound. English is an official language of India, of course Indians are much more likely to seek work in the UK and the US than people from Latin America. You have failed to present any evidence concerning the skill levels of Indian H1B holders, and, moreover, since India has the largest population of all countries, those 130M college graduates must have gone through some very tough selection.

rayinerOP8mo ago

> English is an official language of India, of course Indians are much more likely to seek work in the UK and the US than people from Latin America.

The U.S. is also much closer to Latin America, and has a large Latino community already. The disparity in H1bs (70% versus 2% for Mexico/Brazil/Colombia) is just too huge to explain by language preferences.

> since India has the largest population of all countries, those 130M college graduates must have gone through some very tough selection.

Not at all. Outside the top schools standards plummet. Half of those graduates are not qualified to work in their fields: https://www.tbsnews.net/bloomberg-special/worthless-degrees-...

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

jonathanstrange8mo ago

So the US is more popular among Indians than among Mexicans, Brazilians, and Colombians. What is the point?

And why these countries when I've already said the same about Indians vs. Chinese?

rayinerOP8mo ago

134158mo ago

rayinerOP8mo ago

> English is an official language of India, of course Indians are much more likely to seek work in the UK and the US than people from Latin America.

> since India has the largest population of all countries, those 130M college graduates must have gone through some very tough selection.

Not at all. Outside the top schools standards plummet. Half of those graduates are not qualified to work in their fields: https://www.tbsnews.net/bloomberg-special/worthless-degrees-...

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse