undefined | Better HN

0 pointsCuriouslyC5mo ago0 comments

Does this produce actual lint rules, or are you templating out lint-like replies from a LLM using a response format?

If you're doing inference, just give me a cli that's userless and free. I'm happy to use left over codex plan tokens or gemini free tokens for this, and while the idea seems interesting and I might be upsellable to more features down the line, the price/offering is a non starter.

0 comments

dearilos5mo ago

We combine determinism + LLMs to catch things a human would normally have to. If the LLM finds a violation, it generates a comment.

Big agree on the CLI being open and letting you bring your own inference provider. We’re holding off on it until we get more feedback from some of our hardcore users.

hdjrudni5mo ago

What are you using for "determinism"? Sounds to me like you might just be running eslint + et al and then charging a fee for it.

dearilos5mo ago

We use ast-grep for the determinism part. I should have clarified - we don’t charge for fully deterministic runs. Only ones where the LLM is involved as a judge.

codyswann5mo ago

Is that a "yes" on lint rules? AI needs determinism to block commits because once the slop hits code review, it's already a gigantic waste of time. AI needs self-correcting loops.

dearilos5mo ago

It supports fully deterministic rules, which we use LLMs to help you write.

Agreed on all of this too. This is why we built the CLI tool - to shift left the work.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsCuriouslyC5mo ago0 comments

Does this produce actual lint rules, or are you templating out lint-like replies from a LLM using a response format?

0 comments

dearilos5mo ago

We combine determinism + LLMs to catch things a human would normally have to. If the LLM finds a violation, it generates a comment.

Big agree on the CLI being open and letting you bring your own inference provider. We’re holding off on it until we get more feedback from some of our hardcore users.

hdjrudni5mo ago

What are you using for "determinism"? Sounds to me like you might just be running eslint + et al and then charging a fee for it.

dearilos5mo ago

We use ast-grep for the determinism part. I should have clarified - we don’t charge for fully deterministic runs. Only ones where the LLM is involved as a judge.

codyswann5mo ago

Is that a "yes" on lint rules? AI needs determinism to block commits because once the slop hits code review, it's already a gigantic waste of time. AI needs self-correcting loops.

dearilos5mo ago

It supports fully deterministic rules, which we use LLMs to help you write.

Agreed on all of this too. This is why we built the CLI tool - to shift left the work.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse