undefined | Better HN

0 pointsffsm84mo ago0 comments

That only works if you're not personally responsible for the code you review, too.

0 comments

If they're okay with vibe-coded code, they should be fine with vibe-coded reviews too. You really only should be in a situation where you have more responsibility over your reviews than other people have for their code if you're in charge, and if you're in charge, just ban the practice.

stevula4mo ago

The problem is other people/teams making PRs to your code that you then have to maintain or fix later. It’s in your interest not to half-ass the review, creating an asymmetric amount of work for you vs them.

throwup2384mo ago

Just don’t give the AI agent an “approve_pr” tool. It can only comment or reject.

kortilla4mo ago

But then what? At the end it’s still on you to approve and you have no idea what is hiding in the code.

jjcob4mo ago

You don't approve it. You just slowly grind the submitter down with minor feedback. At some point they lose interest and after a year you can close the PR, or ask the submitter to open a new PR.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse