undefined | Better HN

0 pointsmcastle4mo ago0 comments

Thanks for these considerations. I think even if a debate doesn’t help arrive at an ultimate truth, it can still be beneficial as a substrate for revealing important questions that can then provide a deeper or more nuanced understanding of a given topic.

0 comments

esseph4mo ago

I understand that's the goal, but the end result is that a charismatic debater that engages in emotional rhetoric that can appeal to the audience will "win" over a well-researched academic more often than not.

The outcome is often... less than desirable.

mcastleOP4mo ago

Perhaps asynchronous debate through written word exchanges undertaken over weeks, in the spirit of the Federalist Papers, could help mollify this risk. Logosive supports this format.

I’ve also enjoyed the debate about debate that this discussion has generated, so thank you for that.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse