undefined | Better HN

0 pointsunethical_ban4mo ago0 comments

I don't get your argument. If an ec2 needs access to an s3 resource, doesn't it need that role? Or otherwise, couldn't there be some global s3 URL filter that automagically routes same-region traffic appropriately if it is permitted?

My point is that, architecturally, is there ever in the history of AWS an example where a customer wants to pay for the transit of same-region traffic when a check box exists to say "do this for free"? Authorization and transit/path are separate concepts.

There has to be a better experience.

0 comments

icedchai4mo ago

The EC2 needs credentials, but not necessarily a role. If someone is able to compromise an EC2 instance that has unrestricted S3 connectivity (no endpoint policies), they could use their own credentials to exfiltrate data to a bucket not associated with the account.

unethical_banOP4mo ago

I'll have to dive in and take a look. I'm not arguing, but here is how I naively see it:

It seems there is a gap between "how things are" and "how things should be".

"Transiting the internet" vs. "Cost-free intra-region transit" is an entirely different question than "This EC2 has access to S3 bucket X" or "This EC2 does not have access to S3 bucket X".

Somewhere, somehow, that fact should be exposed in the design of the configuration of roles/permissions/etc. so that enabling cost-free intra-region S3 access does not implicitly affect security controls.

icedchai4mo ago

I agree. The real question is why do I need an "VPC endpoint" to save money in the first place?! us-east-1 EC2 isn't actually going over the internet to connect to us-east-1 S3, regardless or whether it's using a NAT gateway or VPC endpoint. AWS knows what routes are on its own network.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsunethical_ban4mo ago0 comments

There has to be a better experience.

0 comments

icedchai4mo ago

unethical_banOP4mo ago

I'll have to dive in and take a look. I'm not arguing, but here is how I naively see it:

It seems there is a gap between "how things are" and "how things should be".

"Transiting the internet" vs. "Cost-free intra-region transit" is an entirely different question than "This EC2 has access to S3 bucket X" or "This EC2 does not have access to S3 bucket X".

icedchai4mo ago

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse