undefined | Better HN

0 pointsares6236mo ago0 comments

If I had a magic wand I would wish for 2 parallel open source communities diverging from today.

One path continues on the track it has always been on, human written and maintained.

The other is fully on the AI track. Massive PRs with reviewers rubber stamping them.

I’d love to see which track comes out ahead.

Edit: in fact, perhaps there are open source projects already fully embracing AI authored contributions?

0 comments

I agree. It would also work out like a long term supervised learning process though. Humans showing how it's really done, and AI companies taking that as a gold standard for training and development of AI.

ares623OP6mo ago

I'm not so sure. There's already decades of data available for the existing process.

ctenb6mo ago

That is true, but it doesn't help for new languages, frameworks, etc

jebarker6mo ago

How would you define “ahead”?

forgetfulness6mo ago

Able to make changes preserving correctness over time

Vibecoding reminds me sharply of the height of the Rails hype, products quickly rushed to market off the backs of a slurry of gems and autoimports inserted on generated code, the original authors dipping and teams of maintainers then screeching into a halt

Here the bots will pigheadedly heap one 9000 lines PR onto another, shredding the code base to bits but making it look like a lot of work in the process

jebarker6mo ago

Yes, preserving correctness seems like a good metric. My immediate reaction was to think that the parent comment was saying they’d like to see this comparison because AI will come out ahead. On this metric and based on current AI coding it’s hard to see that being the case or even possible to verify.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

ctenb6mo ago

ares623OP6mo ago

I'm not so sure. There's already decades of data available for the existing process.

ctenb6mo ago

That is true, but it doesn't help for new languages, frameworks, etc

jebarker6mo ago

How would you define “ahead”?

forgetfulness6mo ago

Able to make changes preserving correctness over time

Here the bots will pigheadedly heap one 9000 lines PR onto another, shredding the code base to bits but making it look like a lot of work in the process

jebarker6mo ago

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse