undefined | Better HN

0 pointsallturtles3mo ago0 comments

> The point is that someone who chose to work for Google recently could not actually believe that building datacenters is “raping the planet”.

Of course they could. (1) People are capable of changing their minds. His opinion of data centers may have been changed recently by the rapid growth of data centers to support AI or for who knows what other reasons. (2) People are capable of cognitive dissonance. They can work for an organization that they believe to be bad or even evil.

0 comments

SpicyLemonZest3mo ago

It’s possible, yes, for someone to change their mind. But this process comes with sympathy for all the people who haven’t yet had the realization, which doesn’t seem to be in evidence.

Cognitive dissonance is, again, exactly my point. If you sat him down and asked him to describe in detail how some guy setting up a server rack is similar to a rapist, I’m pretty confident he’d admit the metaphor was overheated. But he didn’t sit himself down to ask.

TomatoCo3mo ago

I don't think he claimed that "some guy setting up a server rack" is similar to a rapist. I think he's blaming the corporations. I don't think that individuals can have that big of an effect on the environment (outliers like Thomas Midgley Jr. excepted, of course).

I think "you people" is meant to mean the corporations in general, or if any one person is culpable, the CEOs. Who are definitely not just "some guy setting up a server rack."

SpicyLemonZest3mo ago

It can't mean that, because the people who sent him the email that prompted the complaint are neither corporations nor CEOs.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsallturtles3mo ago0 comments

> The point is that someone who chose to work for Google recently could not actually believe that building datacenters is “raping the planet”.

0 comments

SpicyLemonZest3mo ago

It’s possible, yes, for someone to change their mind. But this process comes with sympathy for all the people who haven’t yet had the realization, which doesn’t seem to be in evidence.

TomatoCo3mo ago

I think "you people" is meant to mean the corporations in general, or if any one person is culpable, the CEOs. Who are definitely not just "some guy setting up a server rack."

SpicyLemonZest3mo ago

It can't mean that, because the people who sent him the email that prompted the complaint are neither corporations nor CEOs.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse