No... nobody has ever argued that.
There's a debate to be had about what any given new technology is good for and how to use it because they all market themselves as the best thing since sliced bread. Fine. I use Sonnet all the time as a research tool, it's kind of great. I've also tried lots of stuff that doesn't work.
But the attitude towards everyone who isn't an AI MAXIMALIST does not persuade anyone or contribute to this debate in any useful way.
Anyway if I get kicked out of the industry for being a heretic I think I'll go open an Italian restaurant. That could be fun.