undefined | Better HN

0 pointsWorkaccount22mo ago0 comments

You said enrolling in insurance was a choice. If everyone with a BMI under 22 who did at least an hour of cardio a week had their own health insurance club, they would be doing excellent with cheap premiums and great care, while everyone else drowned in medical debt as their plans collapsed.

The choice right now is all or nothing. There is no choice for healthy people to only share a plan with other healthy people. If there was, everyone else, especially the least healthy, would be totally screwed.

0 comments

ImPostingOnHN2mo ago

I am still having trouble understand how that pertains to the post to which it replied. Here are those 2 points again:

1. In the US, enrolling in health insurance is currently a choice (I'm can't tell whether your hypothesis about healthy people is agreeing or disagreeing with this point).

2. We don't want Billy to be screwed for life just because he was born to a suboptimal combination of parents.

Would you mind clarifying the connection here, please?

Workaccount2OP2mo ago

1. I'm saying the choice is faux. Healthy people will have dramatically lower medical bills throughout their life, so why shouldn't they get discounted health insurance? Which leads to your second point which I already addressed in my initial post:

2. >This is why there is a hyperfixation on shifting blame away from (failing) individuals. The logic breaks when Billy has to admit he just hates exercising.

ImPostingOnHN2mo ago

> Healthy people will have dramatically lower medical bills throughout their life, so why shouldn't they get discounted health insurance?

I never said they shouldn't. It's just a topic totally unrelated to whether or not people are forced to buy insurance, and I'm not interested in discussing that new, unrelated topic.

> Billy has to admit he just hates exercising.

This logic breaks down when Billy actually exercises and eats just fine, but was nonetheless born to a suboptimal combination of parents.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsWorkaccount22mo ago0 comments

0 comments

ImPostingOnHN2mo ago

I am still having trouble understand how that pertains to the post to which it replied. Here are those 2 points again:

1. In the US, enrolling in health insurance is currently a choice (I'm can't tell whether your hypothesis about healthy people is agreeing or disagreeing with this point).

2. We don't want Billy to be screwed for life just because he was born to a suboptimal combination of parents.

Would you mind clarifying the connection here, please?

Workaccount2OP2mo ago

2. >This is why there is a hyperfixation on shifting blame away from (failing) individuals. The logic breaks when Billy has to admit he just hates exercising.

ImPostingOnHN2mo ago

> Healthy people will have dramatically lower medical bills throughout their life, so why shouldn't they get discounted health insurance?

I never said they shouldn't. It's just a topic totally unrelated to whether or not people are forced to buy insurance, and I'm not interested in discussing that new, unrelated topic.

> Billy has to admit he just hates exercising.

This logic breaks down when Billy actually exercises and eats just fine, but was nonetheless born to a suboptimal combination of parents.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse