undefined | Better HN

0 pointsmadrox27d ago0 comments

If you read the statement, they explicitly state these guardrails don't exist today, and they want to develop them.

Though I have a feeling we're talking about different things. In Claude Code terms, it might want to rm -rf my codebase. You sound like you might want it to never run rm -rf. Anthropic probably wants to catch dangerous commands and send them to humans to approve, like it does today.

0 comments

mvkel27d ago

That's my point. They formed anthropic under the sole mandate of "guardrails first," now seemingly don't have them at all. So they're just another ai company with different marketing, not the purely altruistic outfit they want everyone to believe

xvector27d ago

The ability of some people to never be happy, and to find a way to twist a good situation into bad, will always impress me.

Here we have a company doing something unprecedented but it is STILL not enough for people like you. The DoD could destroy them over this statement, and have indicated an intent to do so, but it's still not enough for you that they stand up to this.

I wonder what life is like being so puritanical and unwilling to accept the good, for it is not perfect! This mindset is the road to a life of bitterness.

mvkel26d ago

It's more that I'm allergic to hypocrisy.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse