The problems you mentioned resonated a lot with me and why I'm building it, any interest in working to solve that together?: https://github.com/smol-machines/smolvm
- a security focused project should NOT default to train people installing by piping to bash. If i try previewing the install script in the browser it forces download instead of showing as plain text. The first thing i see is an argument
# --prefix DIR Install to DIR (default: ~/.smolvm)
that later in the script is rm -rf deleting a lib folder. So if i accidentally pick a folder with ANY lib folder this will be deleted.
- Im not sure what the comparison to colima with krunkit machines is except you don't use vm images but how this works or how it is better is not 100% clear
- Just a minor thing but people don't have much attention and i just saw aws and fly.io in the description and nearly closed the project. it needs to be simpler to see this is a local sandbox with libkrun NOT a wrapper for a remote sandbox like so many of the projects out there.
Will try reaching you on some channel, would love to collaborate especially on devX, i would be very interested in something more reliable and bit more lightweight in placce of colima when libkrun can fully replace vz
1. In comparison with colima with krunkit, I ship smolvm with custom built kernel + rootfs, with a focus on the virtual machine as opposed to running containers (though I enable running containers inside it).
The customizations are also opensource here: https://github.com/smol-machines/libkrunfw
2. Good call on that description!
I've reached out to you on linkedin
It can be dedicated to a single service (or a full OS), runs a real BSD kernel, and provides strong isolation.
Overall, it fits into the "VM is the new container" vision.
Disclaimer: I'm following iMil through his twitch streams (the developer of smolBSD and a contributor to NetBSD) and I truly love what he his doing. I haven't actually used smolBSD in production myself since I don't have a need for it (but I participated in his live streams by installing and running his previews), and my answer might be somewhat off-topic.
More here <https://hn.algolia.com/?q=smolbsd>
At a glance, it's a matter of compatibility, most software has first class support for linux. But very interesting work and I'm going to follow it closely
worked in AWS and specifically with firecracker in the container space for 4 years - we had a very long onboarding doc to dev on firecracker for containers... So I made sure to focus on ease of use here.
