undefined | Better HN

0 pointsthe_cosmos1d ago0 comments

Voltage is _always_ relative; you only ever measure differences between two points. Voltmeters have two probes. Ground is just a convenient reference, not a universal zero. And while Earth can act as a reference or return path in some systems, it’s not perfectly neutral or fixed...it’s just large enough to approximate that in practice. (The interplanetary medium aka aether doesn't exist)

Objects don’t repel because they’re at the same potential. Electrostatic force comes from electric fields due to charge. If two objects truly have zero potential difference and no field between them, there’s no force.

You’re correct that circuits care about voltage differences. After all, all work requires a force gradient of some kind.

0 comments

wat1000023h ago

Can't you define zero as the limit of the potential at infinity? And neutral charge bodies in empty space are generally close to that.

The interplanetary medium absolutely exists. I'm not talking about aether. I'm talking about the soup of dust, gas, and particles that fills space in the solar system. It contains a lot of charged particles, which is what keeps Earth extremely close to neutrally charged. Any deviation from neutral starts attracting positively charged particles and repelling negative, or vice versa, which equalizes the charge.

I didn't say objects repel because they're at the same potential. I said that objects at the same potential will still repel each other if that potential isn't zero.

Seriously, what is this reply? Aether? Objects repelling because they're at the same potential? You seem to have read a comment very different from what I wrote.

the_cosmosOP9h ago

Yeah, I did mistake what you were trying to say. We’re just coming at this from two different sides... physics does have the convention that absolute zero potential is defined at infinity. I was looking at it strictly from a practical circuit perspective, where 'zero' is just wherever we stick the ground probe, and we only ever calculate for the relative deltas. And we generally don't have wires that can make it to the interplanetary medium or the edge of the infinite ground plane :)

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse