undefined | Better HN

0 pointsaenis1mo ago0 comments

That.

We already shipped 3 things this year built using Claude. The biggest one was porting two native apps into one react native app - which was originally estimated to be a 6-7 month project for a 9 FTE team, and ended up being a 2 months project with 2 people. To me, the economic value of a claude subscription used right is in the range of 10-40k eur, depending on the type of work and the developer driving it. If Anthropic jacked the prices 100x today, I'd still buy the licenses for my guys.

Edit: ok, if they charged 20k per month per seat I'd also start benchmarking the alternatives and local models, but for my business case, running a 700M budget, Claude brings disproportionate benefis, not just in time saved in developer costs, but also faster shipping times, reduced friction between various product and business teams, and so on. For the first time we generally say 'yes' to whichever frivolities our product teams come up with, and thats a nice feeling.

0 comments

3 comments · 3 top-level

wg01mo ago

Who's going to review that output for accuracy? We'll leave performance and security as unnecessary luxuries in this age and time.

In my experience, even Claude 4.6's output can't be trusted blindly it'll write flawed code and would write tests that would be testing that flawed code giving false sense of confidence and accomplishment only to be revealed upon closer inspection later.

Additionally - it's age old known fact that code is always easier to write (even prior to AI) but is always tenfold difficult to read and understand (even if you were the original author yourself) so I'm not so sure this much generative output from probabilistic models would have been so flawless that nobody needs to read and understand that code.

Too good to be true.

5 more replies

truetraveller1mo ago

Your estimate of "6-7 month project for a 9 FTE team" was probably waaay off. I mean, what is this mobile app? Without even seeing your app, I would say 2 months TOPS with 2 devs. So, the "AI" version is really not that much better, and probably even worse.

davebren1mo ago

You copied two human coded native apps into a vibe coded react app? If the vibe coding is so good why wouldn't you keep the native apps and vibe code on top of them instead of spending a bunch of money to reach feature parity with a worse version?

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse