undefined | Better HN

0 pointsdrdaeman20d ago0 comments

The way I see it, it’s purely a terminology/nomenclature problem. Consciousness is whatever speaker decides to call so. When listener has a different notion, communication hits a barrier. Language works only because most have somewhat overall similar perceptions on semantics, and it’s easy for everyday stuff (and even then people can easily miscommunicate e.g. colors). Not that many think about nature of consciousness in any fine detail, so for most folks it’s just… a hand-wavy something humans have related to thinking and awareness.

And overhauling the language to match scientific understanding requires getting everyone onboard with that scientific understanding. Good luck with that, given that we have plenty of people who believe in weirdest nonsense.

Brain is not the only thing that makes us conscious, the whole human is a super-weird collection of highly intertwined systems that work together and produce whatever we call “human.” As I get it, it’s a huge complexity all the way down to that gut bacteria that somehow affects our thinking too. And I don’t think we have a vocabulary for all that - we mostly think of “self” as a single entity.

0 comments

tim33320d ago

A way around the nomenclature problems is to try and look at experiments instead. For example Turing seeming frustrated by similar discussions on will machines be able to think that turned on how people defined 'think' and instead proposed his experiment where you can see if people can tell the computer and a human apart by asking questions by text.

I'm not quite sure how you'd apply that to consciousness vs thinking say.

tim33319d ago

Thinking about it consciousness no doubt got there through evolution, as did other aspects of animal life, and functionally, if you think about something like a deer, it increases its survivability to be aware of what's going on, where it is, if there's a predator near, should it run away etc. The inputs are billions of sensory and memory neurons and that info has to be filtered down to something like a situation summary so other parts of the brain can make a decision like whether to stay eating or run. I presume consciousness is basically the situation summary.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

tim33320d ago

I'm not quite sure how you'd apply that to consciousness vs thinking say.

tim33319d ago

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse