Yep and so far it looks like the issue with the meta case is they didnt pay for the book. Not that they used it in training data.

>in the most charitable interpretation, using them to create derivative works.

Yeah in the same way I use a hammer to create a derivative table.

>Someone is a human being with human rights, and if we're going to start pretending that training an LLM is in any way analogous to human consumption and creativity.

I dont care about that. Its simply a tool being built using existing tools. Like using a jigsaw to make a step ladder.