undefined | Better HN

0 pointstriceratops5d ago0 comments

The point I was making was

> [the pope] poses as "conservative" while pushing views strongly opposed to Catholicism."

is a nonsense statement.

The Pope is Catholic and he preaches Catholicism. The Pope doesn't "pose" as anything. Some of what he preaches sounds conservative or liberal or whatever. That doesn't matter to him. What he promulgates was already ancient when any political movement of today was born.

0 comments

erelong5d ago

You're getting at the heart of the matter, try this:

Assume it's true "the pope [appears to be] pushing views strongly opposed to Catholicism".

How does a Catholic interpret that situation?

(Hint: See maybe pope Paul IV's "Cum ex apostolatus officio"?)

triceratopsOP5d ago

> "the pope [appears to be] pushing views strongly opposed to Catholicism"

According to who? It's a safe bet that a pope won't say "actually now you may covet your neighbor's wife" without a head injury or dementia being involved (in which case his staff would cover for him or he'd be retired somehow). That leaves questions of arcane doctrine that a regular Catholic simply isn't qualified to judge. They have the choice of leaving the church or staying and obeying as best they can.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse