undefined | Better HN

0 pointskoko77513y ago0 comments

> Not doing TDD often leads to tightly-coupled brittle software, which can be very fast to implement but also difficult to change down the road. It certainly doesn't have to, but in reality that's what happens 90% of the time.

This is flatly wrong. It may be a tool for productive programmers to keep their code on the right track, but assuming that loosely-coupled code isn't written without it is a huge overreach. Certainly, tests do help, but TDD is just a tool in the toolbox. I have seen many very talented programmers and many of them do not need TDD to produce stable, well-architected projects.

0 comments

mattvanhorn13y ago

I can only speak from my experience (20 years) of developing web apps, but I've never seen a cohesive, loosely coupled web app, that was both over 2 years old AND not using some form of TDD.

koko775OP13y ago

Phrased that way, I agree completely. An established codebase needs to be verified in some ways. But writing code and running it against tests is not exactly equivalent to TDD.

TDD as I understand it is characterized by writing a failing test, followed by implementation code, followed by test-fixing, etc.

However, I can write plenty of good code that does what it's supposed to and works and is stable. THEN I'll refactor as needed, write tests, and since I anticipated my needs, making those tests good and the code testable will be relatively straightforward. That's not TDD, though. It's a pragmatic approach that doesn't prioritize setting requirements (or solidifying an API) over starting simple and iterating quickly.

davesims13y ago

Funny, I had a comment ready before Matt's that started "I can only speak from my experience..."

So, yeah...in my experience this has played out exactly so: in practice, coders who ignore TDD are probably also ignoring a lot of other good practices. The two principles may be "orthogonal" in theory, but the correlation has strong anecdotal support for me.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse