Hopefully those said experts will also out their money where their mouths are and get busy making a competitive alternative that addresses the issues identified.

As bad as the critics make it out I wonder if they have seen it used in the wild by someone non-technical. My mother in law asked me about upgrading her iPad on Sunday. She did so and I expected a bunch of confusion and questions re: photo's and email; the two apps she uses most (besides mindless games that aren't affected by any OS changes whatsoever).

Her comment last nigh? "It's really different I really like how they organized my photos for me."

So that's an n of one. But it's closer to observing it in the wild vs. a small circle of tech savvy perfectionists.

If the critics want me to take them seriously they should not focus on themselves so much but the average person and their experience immediately after upgrading, a day later, a week later and a month later. Otherwise, IMO it's just a whiney tech pundit fishing with link bait.