undefined | Better HN

0 pointsarethuza12y ago0 comments

"Europe hasn't even moved over to automatic transmission yet"

After having a couple of cars with automatic gearboxes (including a 4.4L BMW - so lack of power wasn't the problem) I find that I am much happier with a manual gearbox.

NB I'm not resistant to new technology in cars - my current car has automatic parking and I use it a lot and normally leave the lights on auto as well.

[Note I am in the UK]

0 comments

stinos12y ago

second. I don't know what it is with it exactly, but automatic shifting kills any pleasure in driving I still have. All the ones I tried seem to react to pedal movements too slowly, which I find sometimes even dangerous because I'm not used too it, and I cannot use the engine to do light to intermediate braking anymore.

and normally leave the lights on auto as well.

Why don't you just leave them always on anyway? Or is that not allowed in the UK?

willyt12y ago

It used to freak people out, others would flash their headlights at you if you had them on in the daytime. Now all new cars automatically put sidelights on during daytime anyway, I think its a (pretty sensible) EU regulation.

pistle12y ago

Down-shifting puts extra stress on transmission and engine components which are far harder to replace than brake pads.

If you're heading down a long slope, sure, use the lower gears to add control.

If you're just trying to come down from your amazing commute freeway race into the clover leaf... use the brakes for braking. Most people downshift incorrectly and add unneeded wear to their clutch.

There's few enough sticks out there already... don't leave me one with a beat up clutch.

acct12y ago

Irrelevant amounts of so. Any driving school teaches using engine braking for increased fuel efficiency and decreased wear of brakes. Manual clutches still last for far longer than even high-end automatic ones.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse