undefined | Better HN

0 pointsmadaxe_again11y ago0 comments

I feel like you wanted to write antisemitism. It isn't. Israel have started a war here. There's nothing incendiary about the truth, except to those who prefer lies.

0 comments

Kanbab11y ago

There is an ongoing cold & hot war between Hamas and Israel. Israel maintains checkpoints in the West Bank, and continues to build settlements, while leaving Gaza alone. Hamas undermines West Bank peace by murdering Fatah members, and not negotiating with Israel, claiming they want to ultimately fight all Jews in the world. Furthermore, Mahmoud Abbas in the West Bank joined Hamas in a unity government.

I think you are mistaken about who started the current fighting. In short, among the backdrop of relative calm: 3 Israelis youths were murdered, Israel searched the West Bank, and arrested numerous Hamas individuals, among other suspects. An Arab boy was murdered, Israel arrested numerous Israeli suspects. Hamas begins firing rockets from Gaza. Then Israel began responding with air attacks in Gaza.

madaxe_againOP11y ago

And who murdered those kids? Not Hamas.

And who runs Gaza and the West Bank? Not Hamas.

Who sent in troops and violated the ceasefire, killing children, and precipitating this? Sure as hell not Hamas. Netanyahu.

Finally - the "unity government" you speak ill of was welcomed everywhere as a positive step towards peace - except for in Israel where it's being used as an excuse for war.

laichzeit011y ago

And who began firing rockets from Gaza? "Not Hamas"? I'm not trying to establish order of events here. Just baiting you to acknowledge a factual detail first.

1 more reply

thescrewdriver11y ago

> And who murdered those kids? Not Hamas.

Hamas themselves neither confirms nor denies it [1], so how can you claim that?

[1] http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/07/10/us-palestinians-is...

Kanbab11y ago

Who runs Gaza? If not Hamas, then who?

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

Kanbab11y ago

madaxe_againOP11y ago

And who murdered those kids? Not Hamas.

And who runs Gaza and the West Bank? Not Hamas.

Who sent in troops and violated the ceasefire, killing children, and precipitating this? Sure as hell not Hamas. Netanyahu.

Finally - the "unity government" you speak ill of was welcomed everywhere as a positive step towards peace - except for in Israel where it's being used as an excuse for war.

laichzeit011y ago

And who began firing rockets from Gaza? "Not Hamas"? I'm not trying to establish order of events here. Just baiting you to acknowledge a factual detail first.

1 more reply

thescrewdriver11y ago

> And who murdered those kids? Not Hamas.

Hamas themselves neither confirms nor denies it [1], so how can you claim that?

[1] http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/07/10/us-palestinians-is...

Kanbab11y ago

Who runs Gaza? If not Hamas, then who?

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse