In the message passing approach you dispatch based on the type of the first argument to the method. Because it would be redundant to explicitly write down the argument it is commonly syntactically elided (though not fully in Python) and you get coupling of the methods and the object. This is not a fundamental property of OO but accidental feature found in most OO languages.
In the generic function approach, the dispatch is extended so one can dispatch on the type (among other things) of (ideally) all of its arguments. Julia follows this approach afaik and if one is familiar with the generic function approach it is not a controversial claim at all.
Erik Naggum explains it here in more depth: http://www.xach.com/naggum/articles/3243735416407529@naggum....
No comments yet.
